[Eye on China] 12,200 Programs Closed: What China’s University Reform Means for Europe
“Professor, you need to keep up with the AI era. Why are we still learning outdated methods?”
A student recently challenged the way universities teach. It is a fair question, and one that professors should take seriously. But the answer goes beyond adopting ChatGPT or introducing AI into classrooms. It requires rethinking what universities teach, why they teach it, and which skills will still matter in ten years.
Between 2021 and 2025, Chinese universities revoked or suspended 12,200 undergraduate programs and introduced 10,200 new ones. More than 30% of the nation’s university programs underwent adjustments. As a professor, I was struck by the scale. After spending many months in China, I also began to understand the timing.
Why China plans in decades: Beijing presents China as a civilization carried forward through successive political orders. Its leaders see themselves as heirs to a long history, not only to a revolution. A government that sees itself as one chapter in a very long story measures success in decades, not news cycles. Chinese officials call this strategic patience. Policy in many democracies follows the electoral cycle, with the next election always in view. Beijing presents its advantage as the ability to start things whose results will appear only after today’s leaders have gone. The trade-off is real. Elections let democracies correct course. A centralized plan can carry a mistake a long way before anyone stops it.
The Five-Year Plan turns that long view into decisions. The first Five-Year Plan was launched in 1953. Today the plans hang from two fixed dates. China aims to become a fully modernized socialist country by 2049, the nation’s 100th anniversary, and to “basically” achieve this goal by 2035. The roadmap to 2035 consists of four five-year plans, and China now stands almost precisely at their midpoint. The national plan is an apex plan sitting on top of many other plans, written by ministries, provinces and sectors.
Not every target carries the same weight. In the new energy plan, the non-fossil share of energy consumption is a binding target, while electricity’s share of final energy use, from 30.0% to 35.0%, is an expected one. Officials are judged on binding targets. Expected targets signal direction. The strength of the system lies less in any single number than in continuity: the next plan picks up where this one ends.
Take electrification. Raising electricity’s share of final energy use from 30% to 35% by 2030 means expanding grids, adapting factories and buildings, and electrifying transport. It also means training the people who make those systems work together. A decision about what students learn today is a decision about what the country can build ten years from now.
How China is changing what universities teach: In 2024, Chinese universities eliminated 1,428 undergraduate programs, a 25-fold increase from the 57 programs cut a decade earlier in 2014. Between 2020 and 2024, courses in information management and systems, public administration, and marketing were the most frequently cut, along with product design. AI did not drive all those closures. It does, however, change the value of skills such as compiling reports, analyzing routine data and producing first drafts.
The new programs show where China is placing some of its bets. The ministry has provided support for nine universities and colleges in establishing majors in embodied intelligence, which combines AI with robotics and other physical systems. Agricultural robotics and biomanufacturing also entered the undergraduate catalog. At Tsinghua, more than 440 courses now use AI. That brings the change into existing degrees, where most students will encounter it.
These are two different decisions for university leaders. Where should departments pool their staff and labs to create a new degree? Where should an existing faculty change what it teaches, what students practice and how they are assessed?
The tasks AI takes over were also training: A translator can start from a machine draft. A junior developer can generate routine code and tests. An architect can produce twenty design options in minutes. A building engineering student can generate an energy model and a convincing report before understanding why the building overheats. Each of those tasks once gave beginners repeated practice in making and catching mistakes. Drafting a translation teaches you where meaning shifts. Debugging code teaches you how a system fails. Building an energy model teaches you which assumptions can overturn a result. If students skip those steps, faculty need to teach deliberately the judgment those steps used to develop.
In my own field, I would let students use AI to generate twenty façades, then ask them to defend one on overheating, daylight, embodied carbon, and buildability. In an engineering lab, I would give them a plausible AI-generated model with a flawed assumption. Their job would be to find the flaw, check the model against measurements, and explain whether correcting it changes the design decision. That would change what earns a good grade.
The question I brought back to Europe: The student who challenges outdated teaching methods has a point. But replacing traditional assignments with AI-generated answers is not educational progress. The challenge is to preserve fundamental knowledge while redesigning how students develop independent judgment.
European universities can learn from the timing of China’s reforms. A student entering a five-year degree today will graduate into an industry that has had five more years to reorganize around AI. A curriculum review that starts after those changes are visible will only reach the next cohort.
Perhaps the question is no longer whether professors are keeping up with AI, but whether universities are preparing students to think beyond it.
If we were designing our degrees from scratch today, what would we teach differently, knowing what AI can already do?
📚 Learn more about our research https://www.sbd.uliege.be/
💻 Subscribe to my newsletter https://www.shadyattia.org/#/portal/signup
🅱️ Bilibili b23.tv/bzjL3bn or 🎬 YouTube https://lnkd.in/erHrfkNf
🌐 Explore previous posts and resources https://www.shadyattia.org
🔗 Follow all my professional links, including WeChat 🟩💬 微信 https://lnkd.in/eN3xZhhZ
#HigherEducation #FutureOfWork #IndustrialStrategy #AI #EngineeringEducation #EyeOnChina